Lebensbedingungen und biologischer Lebensstandard in der Vorgeschichte Südwestasiens und Europas: anthropometrische, cliometrische und archäometrische Ansätze
Final Report Abstract
The project LiVES investigated the development of body height between the Mesolithic and Late Bronze Age in South-West Asia and Europe with a team of archaeologists, anthropologists and statisticians. The aim was to investigate the applicability of body height as an approximate value for nutrition during the growth period and thus as a biological measure of well-being in prehistory. To this end, long-bone lengths of 6901 individuals were updated on the basis of two older data collections on archaeological skeletons according to the current state of research in the literature. On this data basis, it was possible for the first time to coherently model the course of body height in the study area and period using a Bayesian algorithm that also takes measurement errors into account. In a further database, 2649 published measurements of stable nitrogen and carbon isotopes were compiled for the working area and period, thus tracing the development of the prehistoric diet. However, the correlation between body height and dietary protein intake during the growth phase postulated by economic historians could not be proven either by analysing the two data sets together or on the basis of a narrowly defined Early Neolithic population (Southwest German Linear Pottery, 2nd half of the 6th millennium BC): Isotope measurement data from teeth (which are formed in childhood and adolescence) and ribs (as a signal from adulthood) had little predictive power with regard to body height. Only after taking into account genetics, which play a decisive role in determining body height, together with diet in adulthood, a further study showedfirst correlations that point to a growth inhibition in women in the Central German Linear Pottery. However, this result still leaves open the question of whether the diet in childhood and adolescence was the cause here, or whether the disadvantage of women is to be localised in the socio-economic-political-emotional or SEPE area. The use of body height as a proxy for the biological standard of living, as successfully pursued by economic historians and development scientists, especially with modern data, therefore requires good (population) genetic control in large-scale spatial and temporal comparisons; in addition, all analyses should take into account that body height is not only determined genetically and by diet, but also represents a social signal that may be additionally modulated by SEPE factors during the growth phase.
Publications
-
Das Rind in Vorgeschichte und traditioneller Landwirtschaft: archäologische und technologisch-ergologische Aspekte. Mitteilungen der Berliner Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte 32, 2011, 81-105.
Masson, A. & Rosenstock, Eva
-
Thomas Meier/Petra Tillessen (Hrsg.), Über die Grenzen und zwischen den Disziplinen. Fächerübergreifende Zusammenarbeit im Forschungsfeld historischer Mensch-Umwelt-Beziehungen, Budapest 2011, Archaeolingua, 507 Seiten. EAZ – Ethnographisch-Archaeologische Zeitschrift, 53(1/2), 122-126.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Eiweißversorgung und Körperhöhe: zur Übertragbarkeit anthropometrischer Ansätze auf die Archäologie. In: W. Schier - M. Meyer (Hrsg.), Vom Nil bis an die Elbe. Forschungen aus fünf Jahrzehnten am Institut für Prähistorische Archäologie der Freien Universität Berlin. Internationale Archäologie – Studia honoraria 36 (Rahden/Westfalen: Leihdorf 2014) 147-163.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Grown Up. The Archaeology of Childhood, 107-127. SUNY Press.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Modeling body height in prehistory using a spatio-temporal Bayesian errors-in variables model. AStA Advances in Statistical Analysis, 100(3), 289-311.
Groß, Marcus
-
The Prize of Urbanization? Biological Standard of Living in the Near East around the 4th millennium. In: M. B. d’Anna - C. Jauß - J. C. Johnson, with individual contributions by (in order of appearance) K. Wagensonner, C. Jauß, S. Pollock, E. Rosenstock, R. Berthon, J. Dahl, J. C. Johnson, M. B. D’Anna and H. Brunke, Food and Urbanization. Material and Textual Perspectives on Alimentary Practice in Early Mesopotamia. Origini. Rivista di Preistoria e Protostoria delle Civiltà Antiche/Prehistory and Protohistory of Ancient Civilizations XXXVII, 37-41.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Das Kind in uns unter der Lupe der Isotopie, Allometrie und Pathologie: Zusammenhang zwischen δ15N und δ13C als Eiweißproxy und dem longitudinalen Knochenwachstum bei adulten, prähistorischen Skelettindividuen unter Berücksichtigung weiterer Indikatoren für Nährstoffversorgung
Hujić, A.
-
Die Vor- und Frühgeschichte des Biers - eine bayerische Perspektive. In: Haus der Bayerischen Geschichte (Hrsg.), Bier in Bayern. Katalog zur Bayerischen Landesausstellung 29.04. - 30.10.2016 (Augsburg: Haus der Bayerischen Geschichte 2016) 13-20.
Scheibner, Alisa & Rosenstock, Eva
-
Messfehlermodelle für die Survey-Statistik und die Wirtschaftsarchäologie
Groß, Marcus
-
Natur und Kultur – Motoren der menschlichen Ernährung. Interview, Ernährungs-Umschau Special „Evolution“ 6/2016, M360- M364.
Rosenstock, Eva; Scheibner, Alisa & Maid-Kohnert, U.
-
Prähistorische Ernährung in Vorderasien und Europa. Eine kulturgeschichtliche Synthese auf der Basis ausgewählter Quellen. Schriften zum Lebensstandard in der Vorgeschichte 1; Berliner Archäologische Forschungen (Rahden: Leidorf 2016). ISBN: 978- 3-89646-526-9, mit Katalog der Isotopendaten auf CD-ROM.
Scheibner, Alisa
-
Von Moränen, Megalithen und Muh: ein archäotechnischer Versuch auf dem Zugrindertreffen 2016. Arche Nova - Fachzeitschrift der Vereine und Verbände zur Erhaltung gefährdeter Nutztierrassen 02/2016
Rosenstock, Eva & Masson, A.
-
Fermentierter Brei und vergorenes Malz: Bier in der Vorgeschichte Südwestasiens und Europas. Mitteilungen der Anthropologischen Gesellschaft Wien 147, 31-62.
Rosenstock, Eva & Scheibner, Alisa
-
Ancient proteins from ceramic vessels at Çatalhöyük West reveal the hidden cuisine of early farmers. Nature Communications, 9(1).
Hendy, Jessica; Colonese, Andre C.; Franz, Ingmar; Fernandes, Ricardo; Fischer, Roman; Orton, David; Lucquin, Alexandre; Spindler, Luke; Anvari, Jana; Stroud, Elizabeth; Biehl, Peter F.; Speller, Camilla; Boivin, Nicole; Mackie, Meaghan; Jersie-Christensen, Rosa R.; Olsen, Jesper V.; Collins, Matthew J.; Craig, Oliver E. & Rosenstock, Eva
-
Economic Prehistory. An Economist’s Guide to Economic History, 251-258. Springer International Publishing.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Where Angel feared not to tread:. Social Dimensions of Food in the Prehistoric Balkans, 320-367. Oxbow Books.
Rosenstock, Eva & Scheibner, Alisa
-
Back to good shape: biological standard of living in the Copper and Bronze Ages and the possible role of food. In: J. Kneisel - W. Kirleis - N. Taylor - M. dal Corso - V. Tiedtke (Hrsg.), The third food revolution? Setting the Bronze Age Table: Production, Subsistence, Diet and Their Implications for European Landscapes. Proceedings of the International Workshop “Socio-environmental dynamics over the last 12.000 years: the creation of landscapes III (15th -18th March 2013)” in Kiel (Habelt: Bonn 2019) 121-151.
Rosenstock, Eva; Groß, Marcus; Hujić, A. & Scheibner, Alisa
-
Changes after the revolution: Uniformity or diversity in Neolithic and Bronze Age diets? In: J. Kneisel - M. Dal Corso - W. Kierleis - H. Scholz - N. Taylor - V. Tiedtke (Hrsg.), The third food revolution? Setting the Bronze Age Table: Common trends in economic and subsistence strategies in Bronze Age Europe. Proceedings of the International Workshop “Socio-environmental dynamics over the last 12.000 years: the creation of landscapes III (15th -18th March 2013)” in Kiel (Habelt: Bonn 2019) 153-178.
Scheibner, Alisa
-
Dusting off ancient anthropometric data banks: The “Mainz Punch Card Archive” and “Geneva ADAM” and their integration with the updated and enlarged LiVES-COstA online data base, Edition Topoi
Ebert, Julia; Martin, Robert; Desideri, J.; Besse, M.; Henke, W.; Groß, Marcus & Rosenstock, Eva
-
Human stature in the Near East and Europe ca. 10,000–1000 BC: its spatiotemporal development in a Bayesian errors-in-variables model. Archaeological and Anthropological Sciences, 11(10), 5657-5690.
Rosenstock, Eva; Ebert, Julia; Martin, Robert; Hicketier, Andreas; Walter, Paul & Groß, Marcus
-
Moraines, megaliths and moo: putting the prehistoric tractor to work. In: J. Müller - M. Hinz - M. Wunderlich (Hrsg.), Megaliths, Societies and Landscapes – Early Monumentality and Social Differentiation in Neolithic Europe. Volume 3 Proceedings of the international conference »Megaliths – Societies – Landscapes. Early Monumentality and Social Differentiation in Neolithic Europe« (16th–20th June 2015) in Kiel (Habelt: Bonn) 1099 – 1111.
Rosenstock, Eva; Masson, A. & Zich, B.
-
Ancient genome-wide DNA from France highlights the complexity of interactions between Mesolithic hunter-gatherers and Neolithic farmers. Science Advances, 6(22).
Rivollat, Maïté; Jeong, Choongwon; Schiffels, Stephan; Küçükkalıpçı, İşil; Pemonge, Marie-Hélène; Rohrlach, Adam Benjamin; Alt, Kurt W.; Binder, Didier; Friederich, Susanne; Ghesquière, Emmanuel; Gronenborn, Detlef; Laporte, Luc; Lefranc, Philippe; Meller, Harald; Réveillas, Hélène; Rosenstock, Eva; Rottier, Stéphane; Scarre, Chris; Soler, Ludovic ... & Haak, Wolfgang
-
Fermentierte Milch. Ernährungs-Umschau 5/2020, M288-294
Rosenstock, Eva & Peitersen, N.
-
LiVES-COstA Digest: Checked and updated entries from the LiVES Collection of Osteological Anthropometry, Edition Topoi 2019
Rosenstock, Eva; Ebert, Julia; Martin, Robert & Groß, Marcus
-
Revolute joints. A contribution to prehistoric machine theory. In: St. Blum – T. Efe - T. Kienlin - E. Pernicka (Hrsg.), From Past to Present. Gedenkschrift für Manfred Korfmann (= Studia Troica Monographien 11) (Bonn: Habelt 2020) 545-557.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Chemischer Hintergrund und Anwendungsmöglichkeiten der Stickstoff- (δ15N) und Kohlenstoff (δ13C)-Isotopenanalyse in der Archäologie In: W. Schier – J. Orschiedt – H. Stäuble – C. Liebermann (Hrsg.), Mesolithikum oder Neolithikum? Auf den Spuren später Wildbeuter. Berlin Studies of the Ancient World 72 (Berlin: Edition Topoi) 329-342
Hujić, A.
-
Cultured Milk. Current Anthropology, 62(S24), S256-S275.
Rosenstock, Eva; Ebert, Julia & Scheibner, Alisa
-
Die Anfänge. Archäologie in Deutschland 01/2021, 21-23.
Rosenstock, Eva & Stika, H.-P.
-
Human diet and the Mesolithic-Neolithic transition in Central Europe - an isotopic view. In: W. Schier – J. Orschiedt – H. Stäuble – C. Liebermann (Hrsg.), Mesolithikum oder Neolithikum? Auf den Spuren später Wildbeuter. Berlin Studies of the Ancient World 72 (Berlin: Edition Topoi 2021) 305-328.
Scheibner, Alisa
-
Ten millennia of hepatitis B virus evolution. Science, 374(6564), 182-188.
Kocher, Arthur; Papac, Luka; Barquera, Rodrigo; Key, Felix M.; Spyrou, Maria A.; Hübler, Ron; Rohrlach, Adam B.; Aron, Franziska; Stahl, Raphaela; Wissgott, Antje; van Bömmel, Florian; Pfefferkorn, Maria; Mittnik, Alissa; Villalba-Mouco, Vanessa; Neumann, Gunnar U.; Rivollat, Maïté; van de Loosdrecht, Marieke S.; Majander, Kerttu; Tukhbatova, Rezeda I. ... & Kühnert, Denise
-
Bandkeramik and Harris: a case study in the spatio-temporal logic of archaeological sites. In: E. Kaiser – M. Meyer – S. Scharl – St. Suhrbier (Hrsg.), Wissensschichten. Festschrift für Wolfram Schier zu seinem 65. Geburtstag. Studia Honoraria (Rahden/Westf. 2022) 179-198.
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Predicting skeletal stature using ancient DNA. American Journal of Biological Anthropology, 177(1), 162-174.
Cox, Samantha L.; Moots, Hannah M.; Stock, Jay T.; Shbat, Andrej; Bitarello, Bárbara D.; Nicklisch, Nicole; Alt, Kurt W.; Haak, Wolfgang; Rosenstock, Eva; Ruff, Christopher B. & Mathieson, Iain
-
Speeding up. Prehistoric animal traction and the revolute joint. In: C. Kropp – L. Zoll (Hrsg.), Draft Animals in the Past, Present and Future (Heidelberg: Propylaeum) 45-62
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Arkeolojik yaklaşımlar: Bira nasıl kanıtlanabilir [Archäologische Ansätze: Wie kann Bier nachgewiesen werden]? Beitrag für das Sonderheft 16 „Zaman değişir bira değişmez [Die Zeiten ändern sich, Bier ändert sich nicht]“ des populären türkischen Archäologie-Magazins ArkeoDuvar
Rosenstock, Eva
-
Socio-cultural practices may have affected sex differences in stature in Early Neolithic Europe. Nature Human Behaviour, 8(2), 243-255.
Cox, Samantha L.; Nicklisch, Nicole; Francken, Michael; Wahl, Joachim; Meller, Harald; Haak, Wolfgang; Alt, Kurt W.; Rosenstock, Eva & Mathieson, Iain
-
Cross-dating 30 years on: an archaeological-chronometric approach to the Linear Pottery culture. In: H. Piezonka – J. Schneeweiß – H. Schwarzberg – M. Nawroth (Hrsg.), Man sieht nur, was man weiß. Man weiß nur, was man sieht. Globalhistorische Perspektiven auf interkulturelle Phänomene der Mobilität. Festschrift für Hermann Parzinger zum 65. Geburtstag (=Prähistorische Archäologie in Südosteuropa 33) (Rahden/Westfalen 2024), 541-554.
Rosenstock, Eva
