Volatile waters and the hydrosocial anthropocene: a comparative study of life in major river deltas
Human Geography
Final Report Abstract
Volatile Waters studied everyday life in four geographically and ethnographically diverse river deltas, focusing on the intersections of a shifting material landscape with social, economic and cultural transformations. Based on ethnographic studies, the project thereby reversed the more common framework of approaching life in river deltas through remote sensing and large data sets. Project researchers conducted ethnographic fieldwork in the Ayeyarwady Delta (Myanmar), the Mackenzie Delta (Canada), the Parnaíba Delta (Brazil) and the Sine-Saloum Delta (Senegal). The project developed the term "volatility" for socio-material analysis, as a concept emphasizing always uncertain and potentially rapid and profound transformations in delta inhabitants’ lives. The project also devised ways of describing delta life as aspects of a "hydrosocial Anthropocene", grounding the sweeping claims of the Anthropocene discourse in concrete and historically specific relations with water. The project’s main findings include the in-depth analysis of situated practices of inhabiting rapidly transforming landscapes, distilling regionally specific issues and comparing similarities and differences across world regions. The research developed a theoretical foundation for anthropologically approaching volatile delta environments, focusing on movements, rhythms and other dynamics that characterize both material and sociocultural processes in river deltas. It also experimented with methodological tools to ethnographically explore such life, from walks and boating trips to the general handling of ubiquitous uncertainty that shapes not just many aspects of delta life, but also ethnographic research practice. Subsequently, the project worked out ways of writing, filming, exhibiting and otherwise representing the things researchers had learned during fieldwork. It produced academic publications alongside outputs directed at wider audiences, including a museum exhibition, a coffee-table book, and audiovisual material; the production of a comic is currently in progress. All publications emphasize that the climatic, hydrological and economic crises that characterize river deltas as global change hotspots matter to delta inhabitants in relation to longer-established, and often more pressing concerns, including political conditions, colonial legacies, or sociocultural marginalization. What looks like novel crises from above are therefore merely new facets of older challenges when seen from below. However, delta dwellers often show remarkable resilience in the face of what to outside observers appear like insurmountable challenges in the face of global warming, sea level rise, etc. The project documents the noteworthy improvisations through which delta inhabitants have long made ends meet, as well as their attitudes towards what may look like radical transformations to outsiders. Where some people see catastrophe and change, delta inhabitants may see routine and continuity.
Publications
-
2017. ‘Constructing the Tana Delta: Imaginaries, Scales and Placeness of Watery Infrastructure’. In Social Water, edited by Franz Krause, Tijo Salverda, Andrea Hollington, Oliver Tappe, Sinah Kloß, and Nina Schneider, np. Voices from Around the World. Cologne: GSSC
Simon, Sandro
-
2017. ‘How Can We (Not) Compare with Cultural Relativism?’ Boasblog: Kulturrelativismus Und Aufklärung. 30 May 2017
Krause, Franz
-
2017. ‘Is a River “Infrastructure”? Thinking about Timber Transport on the Kemi River in Finnish Lapland.’ In Social Water, edited by Franz Krause, Tijo Salverda, Andrea Hollington, Oliver Tappe, Sinah Kloß, and Nina Schneider, np. Voices from Around the World. Cologne: Global South Studies Center
Krause, Franz
-
Eds. 2017. Social Water. Voices from Around the World. Cologne: Global South Studies Center
Krause, Franz; Tijo Salverda; Andrea Hollington; Oliver Tappe; Sinah Kloß & Nina Schneider
-
Towards an Amphibious Anthropology of Delta Life. Human Ecology, 45(3), 403-408.
Krause, Franz
-
2018 Fearing Together, Fearing Alone: Fieldwork Under the Possibility of Fire. In Delta Methods: Reflections on Researching Hydrosocial Lifeworlds, edited by Franz Krause, 57-68. Kölner Arbeitspapiere Zur Ethnologie 7
Simon, Sandro
-
2018. ‘Around and Around: ‘Kyauk Pyin’, Alluvial Lands and the Challenges of Ethnographing Volatility in the Ayeyarwady River Delta’. In Delta Methods: Reflections on Researching Hydrosocial Lifeworlds, edited by Franz Krause, 42-48. Kölner Arbeitspapiere Zur Ethnologie 7
Ivars, Benoit
-
2018. ‘Introducing Delta Methods’. In Delta Methods: Researching Hydrosocial Lifeworlds, edited by Franz Krause, 6–10. Kölner Arbeitspapiere Zur Ethnologie 7
Krause, Franz
-
2018. ‘Of Salt and Drought - What Methods for Ethnographic Research in Fluid Places?’ In Delta Methods: Reflections on Researching Hydrosocial Lifeworlds, edited by Franz Krause, 28-35. Kölner Arbeitspapiere Zur Ethnologie 7
Horisberger, Nora
-
2018. ‘Trapping Trappers, and Other Challenges of Ethnographic Fieldwork in the Mackenzie Delta’. In Delta Methods: Reflections on Researching Hydrosocial Lifeworlds, edited by Franz Krause, 49–56. Kölner Arbeitspapiere Zur Ethnologie 7
Krause, Franz
-
Ed. 2018. Delta methods: Reflections on researching hydrosocial lifeworlds. Cologne Working Papers in Social and Cultural Anthropology, 7
Krause, Franz
-
2019 ‘Emotion and Epistemic Murkiness: Fieldwork Under the Possibility of Fire.’ Sentio 1: 61-67
Simon, Sandro
-
2019 ‘mollUScs + MOLLusCS.’ In Catalogue for the Artbook Fair 'I Never Read', edited by E. Wüthrich, np. Basel: Art Basel
Simon, Sandro
-
2019. ‘Grounded and Global: Water Infrastructure Development and Policymaking in the Ayeyarwady Delta, Myanmar.’ Water Alternatives 12 (3): 1038-1063
Ivars, Benoit & Venot, Jean-Philippe
-
2019. “Hydro-perspectivism: terrestrial life from a watery angle.” Anthropological Notebooks 25(2): 93–101
Krause, Franz
-
Ethnographic conversations with Wittfogel’s ghost: An introduction. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space, 37(7), 1151-1160.
Ley, Lukas & Krause, Franz
-
2020. ‘Volatility’. DELTA Project Blog. 6 April 2020
Krause, Franz; Nora Horisberger; Benoit Ivars; Sandro Simon & Teresa Cremer
-
Alluvial Tactics: Land Access and Control on the Ayeyarwady River. Journal of Burma Studies, 24(1), 37-78.
Ivars, Benoit
-
Claiming and re-claiming the Ayeyarwady Delta, time and again: the case of Nyaungdone Island, Myanmar. Journal of Political Ecology, 27(1).
Ivars, Benoit & Venot, Jean-Philippe
-
Conditions. Anthropocene Unseen, 83-87.
Krause, Franz
-
Presence and Absence in Mollusc Lifeworlds and Visual Essays. Anthrovision, 8.2.
Simon, Sandro
-
Available, Yet Unavailable:. Delta Life, 199-221.
Ivars, Benoit
-
Delta Life.
Krause, Franz & Mark Harris (Eds.)
-
Economy, Identity and Hydrology:. Delta Life, 103-125.
Krause, Franz
-
Gleaning Time:. Delta Life, 151-171.
Simon, Sandro
-
Now what? Repositioning anthropology vis‐à‐vis climate change activism. Social Anthropology, 29(1), 229-231.
Krause, Franz
-
Slippery land, ever-shifting boundaries: claiming and accessing alluvial (is)lands in the Ayeyarwady Delta, Myanmar. Journal of Political Ecology, 28(1).
Ivars, Benoit; Gruel, Charles-Robin; Ngone, Oo The & Venot, Jean-Philippe
-
The Tempo of Solid Fluids: On River Ice, Permafrost, and Other Melting Matter in the Mackenzie Delta. Theory, Culture & Society, 39(2), 31-52.
Krause, Franz
-
Water and Materiality. Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Anthropology.
Krause, Franz
-
‘This Tide Will Be a Good Tide’:. Delta Life, 127-149.
Horisberger, Nora
-
2022. Deltawelten | Delta Worlds: Leben Zwischen Land Und Wasser | Life between Land and Water. Berlin: Reimer
Krause, Franz; Nora Horisberger; Benoit Ivars & Sandro Simon
-
2022. ‘Bidonville–Bidonmondes.’ Anthropology News website, 12.08.2022
Simon, Sandro
-
2022. ‘Rhythm and Aesthetics in Waterwork and Audiovisual Practice’. Entanglements 5 (1/2): 233-243
Simon, Sandro
-
2022. ‘Rhythmic Aesthetic Formations: Multimodal Explorations.’ Entanglements 5 (1/2): 199-207
Cook, Ian M.; Hänsch, Valerie & Sandro Simon
-
Conclusion. Confluences and Distributaries in Delta Life. Delta Life, 222-230.
Krause, Franz & Harris, Mark
-
Inhabiting a transforming delta. American Ethnologist, 49(1), 7-19.
KRAUSE, FRANZ
-
Introduction. Life at Water’s Edge. Delta Life, 1-25.
Krause, Franz & Harris, Mark
-
Rhythms of wet and dry: Temporalising the land-water nexus. Geoforum, 131, 252-259.
Krause, Franz
-
2023. ‘Fluchtlinien der Erfahrung. Multimodale Widerspenstigkeit entlang der Siemensbahn Berlin.’ AG Umweltethnologie Blog. 11. January 2023
Ritz, Anna Maria & Sandro Simon
-
Afterword: Wet Ethnographies. Ethnos, 89(3), 500-509.
Krause, Franz
-
Climate Change as Colonial Echo in the Canadian Arctic. Anthropology and Climate Change, 170-180.
Krause, Franz
-
Eds. 2023. Volatility: Making and Unmaking Liveable Worlds. Special Issue in Social Anthropology / Anthropologie Sociale 31(4)
Krause, Franz & Thomas Hylland Eriksen
-
Environmental Anthropology.
Bollig, Michael & Krause, Franz
-
Inhabiting Volatile Worlds. Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, 31(4), 1-13.
Krause, Franz & Eriksen, Thomas Hylland
-
Rhythming Volatilities. Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, 31(4), 134-153.
Simon, Sandro
-
The Art of Gleaning and Not Becoming Domesticated in Mollusc Waterworlds. Ethnos, 89(3), 480-499.
Simon, Sandro
-
Thinking Like a River.
Krause, Franz
-
Valued Volatility. Social Anthropology/Anthropologie Sociale, 31(4), 154-173.
Krause, Franz
-
Touching Excess: Haptic Sound from the Multispecies Delta. Journal of Sonic Studies, 25.
Sandro, Simon
