OrgIntCEE - The Missing Link: Examining organized interests in post-communist policy-making
Final Report Abstract
While great scholarly effort has been dedicated to understanding how Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries transformed from one-party monopolies to democracy and from communism to capitalism, post-communist organized interests as key voices of civil society have received comparably little attention. This is surprising due to the unique trajectory of civil society in CEE. Communist regimes regulated all civic participation, while marginalizing or outlawing dissident movements. However, the collapse of communism is generally considered an enormous triumph of civil societies, as civic movements (e.g. Solidarność) ultimately brought communism to its knees. In the 1990s though, these fragile new democracies were ultimately navigated through the challenges of post-communist by technocratically operating executives. Low associational membership, low trust and weak consultative procedures were defining features of postcommunism, leading to a perception of CEE interest organizations as weak and ineffective. Yet reform-oriented governments soon aimed to appear more responsive to citizens and created new platforms for civic engagement, a trend reinforced by the spread of Western European norms. European integration brought about opportunities for transnational learning. Thus, the strength of post-communist organized interests was perhaps underestimated. Based on qualitative and quantitative methods, the project systematically explored organized interests in four CEE countries – Poland, Hungary, Czechia, Slovenia – in three policy areas key to their long-term viability – energy, healthcare and higher education. The OrgIntCEE project revolved around five analytical and empirical building blocks. First, we were interested in population ecologies, i.e., how the breakdown of communism, Europeanization and recent trends towards illiberalism in CEE affected organizational birth and death rates. Secondly, we explored interest intermediation structures, i.e. how interest organizations are incorporated into the political process, interact with other stakeholders and where they lobby. Third, we systematically analyzed the determinants of organizations’ political access and influence (e.g. resources, expertise, professionalization, inter-organizational cooperation, etc.). A fourth building block focused on how European/international ties affect CEE organizations, their internal development and lobbying strength. Closely linked to this is our “coming-of-age” dimension focusing on organizational professionalization, multi-level lobbying and expertisesharing with policy-makers. Recently, we increasingly explored how organized interests are coping with “democratic backsliding” and closing political opportunity structures in the region.
Publications
-
“The New Research Agenda of Examining Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making” Rocznik Instytutu Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej / Yearbook of the Institute of East-Central Europe 16(5), 61-79. (2018)
Dobbins, Michael & Riedel, Rafał
-
Organised Interests in the Energy Sector: A Comparative Study of the Influence of Interest Groups in Czechia and Hungary. Politics and Governance, 7(1), 139-151.
Horváthová, Brigitte & Dobbins, Michael
-
State-labour relations in illiberal times: The dissolution of social dialogue in Hungary. The European Social Model under Pressure, 89-106. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Labanino, Rafael
-
Europeizacja zorganizowanych grup interesu w wybranych państwach Europy Środkowej i Wschodniej. Rocznik Instytutu Europy Środkowo-Wschodniej, 18(4), 147-169.
Riedel, Rafał & Czarnecki, Szczepan
-
Explaining the Formation Rates of Post-Communist Interest Organizations: Density Dependence and Political Opportunity Structure. East European Politics and Societies: and Cultures, 35(4), 1043-1067.
Labanino, Rafael Pablo; Dobbins, Michael; Czarnecki, Szczepan & Železnik, Ana
-
Udział organizacji pacjentów w kształtowaniu polityki ochrony zdrowia w Polsce - "koszmar partycypacji" czy remedium na "deficyt demokracji"?. Studia z Polityki Publicznej, 3(27)), 47-63.
Piotrowska, Emilia
-
‘The goal is not necessarily to sit at the table’—Resisting autocratic legalism in Hungarian academia. Higher Education Quarterly, 76(3), 521-536.
Labanino, Rafael & Dobbins, Michael
-
ADVOCACY ORGANISATIONS IN CEE HEALTHCARE – DOES EXPERTISE MATTER?. Europolity - Continuity and Change in European Governance, 15(2).
CZARNECKI, Szczepan; RIEDEL, Rafał & SZYSZKOWSKA, Emilia
-
Analyzing varieties of (post-enlargement) Europeanization in CEE advocacy organizations across policy fields. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 430-453.
Czarnecki, Szczepan & Riedel, Rafał
-
At the crossroads of Europeanization and professionalization. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 197–214.
Czarnecki, Szczepan & Riedel, Rafał
-
Explaining institutional persistence and change in Polish and Czech higher education from a stakeholder perspective. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 173–193.
Vlk, Aleš; Dobbins, Michael & Riedel, Rafał
-
Explaining the density of post-communist interest group populations—resources, constituencies, and regime change. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 321-344.
Labanino, Rafael; Dobbins, Michael & Horváthová, Brigitte
-
Exploring interest intermediation in Central and Eastern Europe: is higher education different?. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 399-429.
Dobbins, Michael; Horváthová, Brigitte & Labanino, Rafael Pablo
-
Exploring interest intermediation in Central and Eastern European healthcare. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 95–123.
Dobbins, Michael; Piotrowska, Emilia & von Bronk, Maximilian
-
Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making. Routledge.
Dobbins, Michael & Riedel, Rafał
-
Exploring populations of organized interests in post-communist Central and Eastern Europe. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 47–76.
Dobbins, Michael; Labanino, Rafael & Horváthová, Brigitte
-
Exploring the links between macroand micro-level factors mediating interest group access to policy-makers” - Online General Conference of the European Consortium for Political Research, 30.08-3.09.2021
Labanino, Rafael, Dobbins, Michael & Horvath, Brigitte
-
Green advocacy and the climate and energy policy access in Central Eastern Europe. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 127–144.
Czarnecki, Szczepan; Emilia, Piotrowska & Riedel, Rafał
-
In Search of Civic Participation. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 79–94.
Czarnecki, Szczepan
-
Interest group access in CEE in the healthcare sector. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 145–172.
Dobbins, Michael; Piotrowska, Emilia & von Bronk, Maximilian
-
Interest groups and political parties in Central and Eastern Europe. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 376-398.
Czarnecki, Szczepan & Piotrowska, Emilia
-
Rounding up our journey through the world of organized interests in the post-communist CEE region. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 277–294.
Dobbins, Michael; Piotrowska, Emilia & Riedel, Rafał
-
The “Missing Link.” Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 3–21.
Dobbins, Michael & Riedel, Rafał
-
There Is No Tabula Rasa – the effect of varieties of communism on organizational formation rates in pre-transition interest group populations. Exploring Organized Interests in Post-Communist Policy-Making, 25–46.
Labanino, Rafael; Dobbins, Michael & Riedel, Rafał
-
Towards a better understanding of organized interests in Central and Eastern Europe. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 307-320.
Riedel, Rafał & Dobbins, Michael
-
Towards energy policy corporatism in Central and Eastern Europe?. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 347-375.
Horváthová, Brigitte; Dobbins, Michael & Labanino, Rafael Pablo
-
When illiberalism looms-mortality anxiety and the perceived existential threat among Polish and Slovenian interest groups. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 10(4), 454-477.
Kamiński, Paweł & Riedel, Rafał
-
“Explaining Participation and Advocacy Patterns in Central and Eastern European Illiberal Democracies”, Workshop on Policy Advice in De-democratizing and Undemocratic Contexts, Gothenburg 18-19.11.2021
Riedel, R.
-
“Post truth post-communism or to much ado about nothing? Trajectories of civil society in a de-democratizing context” - Workshop at the Institute for Sociology, Centre for Social Sciences, Budapest, 17-19.11 2021 & Workshop on Policy Advice in De-democratizing and Undemocratic Contexts, Gothenburg 18-19.11.2021
Dobbins, Michael, Labanino, Rafael Pablo & Horvath, Brigitte
-
Are post-communist interest organizations learning to lobby? Exploring the “coming-of-age” of Central and Eastern European interest groups. Democratization, 29(7), 1268-1290.
Dobbins, Michael; Horváth, Brigitte & Labanino, Rafael Pablo
-
Exploring the domestic and international drivers of professionalization of Central and Eastern European interest groups. European Political Science Review, 14(2), 263-280.
Dobbins, Michael; Horvath, Brigitte & Labanino, Rafael Pablo
-
Here's what you can learn from new data on post-communist interest groups, 3Streams (2022)
Labanino, Rafael
-
Interest Representation Preconditions in Illiberal Poland and Hungary. Studia Europejskie - Studies in European Affairs, 26(1), 47-62.
Riedel, Rafał & Szyszkowska, Emilia
-
Multilevel Venue Shopping Amid Democratic Backsliding in New European Union Member States. Politics and Governance, 11(1).
Labanino, Rafael & Dobbins, Michael
-
Organized interests in post-communist policy-making: a new dataset for comparative research. Interest Groups & Advocacy, 12(1), 73-101.
Dobbins, Michael; Labanino, Rafael Pablo; Riedel, Rafał; Czarnecki, Szczepan; Horváth, Brigitte & Szyszkowska, Emilia
-
“A Strange Case of Non-resistance - the Restructuring of the Hungarian Higher Education Sector”. ECPR General Conference. University of Innsbruck, 22-26.08.2022
Labanino, Rafael Pablo & Dobbins, Michael
-
“No Country for Sick Men. The paradox of patients' empowerment in Poland” at the ECPR Joint Sessions Group “The Political Determinants of Health in the EU”, workshop venue: Friends House, London / UK, 20.06.22
Riedel, Rafał
-
Democratic Backsliding and Organized Interests in Central and Eastern Europe: An Introduction. Politics and Governance, 11(1), 1-4.
Labanino, Rafael Pablo & Dobbins, Michael
-
Interest groups in Central and Eastern Europe have become an endangered species, The Loop, the political science blog of the European Consortium for Political Research (No.25) (2023)
Labanino, Rafael
-
Orgintcee Population Ecology and Survey Datasets (2023)
Dobbins, Michael, Labanino, Rafael Pablo Riedel, Rafał, Czarnecki, Szczepan, Horváth, Brigitte & Szyszkowska, Emilia
-
“The political determinants of the health care policy inertia in Poland” at the online workshop dedicated to the JHPPL special issue, University of Edinburgh, 06.03.2023
Riedel, Rafał
