Consumption-based accounts of land-use change related carbon emissions – CoBALUCE
Final Report Abstract
The expansion and intensification of areas under agricultural and forestry are the main driver of impacts of land use on ecosystems. One main manifestation of these impacts are changes in the carbon stored in ecosystems – for instance if forests are cleared for livestock grazing or the growing of crops. Emissions due to land use and land cover change (or FOLU-emissions) are estimated to presently contribute ~10% to total annual greenhouse gas emissions and about a third to total cumulative emissions historically. An increasingly important driver of ongoing land-use changes and agricultural expansion is the production of products for export markets. Consumption-based accounts (or footprints) of land use and related FOLU emissions - that attribute emissions to the trade and consumption of agricultural and forestry products - can complement territorial accounts (i.e. accounts that monitor where the emissions occur). In CoBALUCE, we focused on the establishment of such consumption-based accounts. A part of the work has focused on establishing consistent global accounts of FOLU-emissions that form the baseline for establishing links to agricultural and forestry products. A main finding here was the large role the perspective or baseline plays for such accounts. We explored two contrasting perspectives. (i) Looking at recent land use changes (above all, ongoing tropical deforestation) and emissions caused by them. (ii) Looking at opportunity costs, asking how much carbon could be taken up by lands in the absence of land use and relating this to the output of the lands. We then attributed the FOLU-emissions to individual agricultural products (e.g., maize, beef) or sectors. Again, here, different assumptions strongly influence the allocation of emissions. However, certain products (e.g. palm oil from Southeast Asia, soybeans from Latin America) appear as major driver of FOLU emissions, regardless of the approach taken. In a last step, we linked the attributed emissions to datasets and models of global trade networks in order to establish links to consumption. In addition, we were also able to produce consumption-based accounts of pressures on ecosystems related to land use change, such as biodiversity decline and the disturbance of intact forest landscapes. Overall, our work shows that a quarter to a third of global FOLU emissions are linked to international trade. The EU and China appear as major importers and consumers of exports linked to high emissions, often originating from tropical regions. These overall patterns also hold in an opportunity cost approach, although the picture is more nuanced when looking at details. The relevance of the work is also shown by the fact that our work has directly contributed to discussions around the EU’s recent regulation to ban the trade with products grown on recently deforested lands. Another major finding was the potentially large role that forestry plays with regards to FOLU emissions, however, present models are not well suited to capture and robustly quantify this role.
Publications
-
Agricultural and forestry trade drives large share of tropical deforestation emissions. Global Environmental Change, 56, 1-10.
Pendrill, Florence; Persson, U. Martin; Godar, Javier; Kastner, Thomas; Moran, Daniel; Schmidt, Sarah & Wood, Richard
-
Increasing impacts of land use on biodiversity and carbon sequestration driven by population and economic growth. Nature Ecology & Evolution, 3(4), 628-637.
Marques, Alexandra; Martins, Inês S.; Kastner, Thomas; Plutzar, Christoph; Theurl, Michaela C.; Eisenmenger, Nina; Huijbregts, Mark A. J.; Wood, Richard; Stadler, Konstantin; Bruckner, Martin; Canelas, Joana; Hilbers, Jelle P.; Tukker, Arnold; Erb, Karlheinz & Pereira, Henrique M.
-
Deforestation risk embodied in production and consumption of agricultural and forestry commodities 2005-2017 (1.0)
Pendrill, F., Persson, U. M. & Kastner, T.
-
"Agricultural trade and its impacts on cropland use and the global loss of species habitat." - Supplementary data (1.0)
Schwarzmüller, F. & Kastner, T.
-
Altered growth conditions more than reforestation counteracted forest biomass carbon emissions 1990–2020. Nature Communications, 12(1).
Le Noë, Julia; Erb, Karl-Heinz; Matej, Sarah; Magerl, Andreas; Bhan, Manan & Gingrich, Simone
-
Data supplement for "Global agricultural trade and land system sustainability: implications for ecosystem carbon storage, biodiversity and human nutrition"
Kastner, T., Chaudhary, A., Gingrich, S., Marques, A., Persson, U. M., Bidoglio, G., Le Provost, G. & Schwarzmüller, F.
-
Flawed numbers underpin recommendations to exclude commodities from EU deforestation legislation (No. 2021:02), Focali Brief. Focali, Göteborg, Sweden.
Persson, M., Kastner, T. & Pendrill, F.
-
Global agricultural trade and land system sustainability: Implications for ecosystem carbon storage, biodiversity, and human nutrition. One Earth, 4(10), 1425-1443.
Kastner, Thomas; Chaudhary, Abhishek; Gingrich, Simone; Marques, Alexandra; Persson, U. Martin; Bidoglio, Giorgio; Le Provost, Gaëtane & Schwarzmüller, Florian
-
Land use intensification increasingly drives the spatiotemporal patterns of the global human appropriation of net primary production in the last century. Global Change Biology, 28(1), 307-322.
Kastner, Thomas; Matej, Sarah; Forrest, Matthew; Gingrich, Simone; Haberl, Helmut; Hickler, Thomas; Krausmann, Fridolin; Lasslop, Gitta; Niedertscheider, Maria; Plutzar, Christoph; Schwarzmüller, Florian; Steinkamp, Jörg & Erb, Karl‐Heinz
-
Quantifying and attributing land use-induced carbon emissions to biomass consumption: A critical assessment of existing approaches. Journal of Environmental Management 286, 112228.
Bhan, M., Gingrich, S., Roux, N., Le Noë, J., Kastner, T., Matej, S., Schwarzmueller, F. & Erb, K.-H.
-
Agricultural trade and its impacts on cropland use and the global loss of species habitat. Sustainability Science, 17(6), 2363-2377.
Schwarzmueller, Florian & Kastner, Thomas
-
Changes in perspective needed to forge ‘no‐regret’ forest‐based climate change mitigation strategies. GCB Bioenergy, 14(3), 246-257.
Erb, Karl‐Heinz; Haberl, Helmut; Le Noë, Julia; Tappeiner, Ulrike; Tasser, Erich & Gingrich, Simone
-
Data supplement for "Land use intensification increasingly drives the spatiotemporal patterns of the global human appropriation of net primary production in the last century" (1.01)
Kastner, T., Matej, S., Forrest, M., Gingrich, S., Haberl, H., Hickler, T., Krausmann, F., Lasslop, G., Niedertscheider, M., Plutzar, C., Schwarzmüller, F., Steinkamp, J. & Erb., K.-H.
-
Embodied HANPP of feed and animal products: Tracing pressure on ecosystems along trilateral livestock supply chains 1986–2013. Science of The Total Environment, 851, 158198.
Roux, Nicolas; Kaufmann, Lisa; Bhan, Manan; Le Noe, Julia; Matej, Sarah; Laroche, Perrine; Kastner, Thomas; Bondeau, Alberte; Haberl, Helmut & Erb, Karlheinz
-
Product level dataset on embodied Human Appropriation of Net Primary Production [Data set]. (1.0.1)
Roux Nicolas, Kaufmann Lisa, Matej Sarah, Kastner Thomas, Bondeau Alberte, Haberl Helmut & Erb Karlheinz
-
Multi-model assessment identifies livestock grazing as a major contributor to variation in European Union land and water footprints. Nature Food, 4(7), 575-584.
Vanham, Davy; Bruckner, Martin; Schwarzmueller, Florian; Schyns, Joep & Kastner, Thomas
-
Risk of intact forest landscape loss goes beyond global agricultural supply chains. One Earth, 6(1), 55-65.
Kan, Siyi; Chen, Bin; Persson, U. Martin; Chen, Guoqian; Wang, Yutao; Li, Jiashuo; Meng, Jing; Zheng, Heran; Yang, Lan; Li, Rui; Du, Mingxi & Kastner, Thomas
