Infrared Ion Spectroscopy for the Gas-Phase Characterization of Organo- and Biocatalysis Intermediates
Physical Chemistry of Molecules, Liquids and Interfaces, Biophysical Chemistry
Final Report Abstract
According to the project objectives detailed in our funding application, we investigated the generation, structure and chemical reactivity of important reactive intermediates in organo- and biocatalysis in the gas-phase: (A) the so-called Breslow intermediates of carbene-based Umpolung, and (B) hydroxycarbenes. In both parts of our projects we successfully applied electrospray ionization (ESI) for phase transfer from the condensed phase to the gas phase and generated and probed selected ionic species with Tandem Mass Spectrometry and Infrared Ion Spectroscopy to gain fundamental insights on chemical reactivity of labile and delicate reactive intermediates. Firstly, the structure and reactivity of isolated Breslow intermediates (BIs, chemically: aminoenols) were studied without any influence of counterions or stabilization of a solvate shell in the gas phase on the molecular level. We accomplished a fundamental study of a comprehensive set of tailor-made BIs in the gas phase. In doing so, we complemented condensed phase NMR spectroscopy and x-ray crystallography data of the solid state, with IR ion spectroscopy of isolated BIs and their keto-tautomers investigated in the gas phase [see M. Paul et al., Breslow Intermediates (Aminoenols) and their Keto Tautomers: First Gas-Phase Characterization by IR Ion Spectroscopy, Chemistry a European Journal 27 (2021) 2662-2669.] The respective report was highly ranked as a "very important paper" by the publisher Wiley, and received further recognition and attention by a Cover in Chem. Eur. J.. Related to that important study we extended our analytical arsenal to ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) to probe the three-dimensional shape of N- heterocyclic carbenes (NHC). This work was done in collaboration with Professor Helmut Schwarz at the TU Berlin and yielded another set of important results and a well-received contribution [M. Paul, et al., Intermediates of N-Heterocyclic Carbene (NHC) Dimerization Probed in the Gas Phase by Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry: C-H···꞉C Hydrogen Bonding vs. Covalent Dimer Formation, Chemistry A European Journal 25 (2019) 2511-2518.]. With this study we were able to detect and analyze the non-covalent intramolecular C-H···꞉C hydrogen bonding interactions in dimeric NHCs. This paper marks a trailblazing IMS analysis of NHC organocatalysts in the gas phase. Secondly, we turned our attention to gas-phase studies of tunneling phenomena, in particular to quantum mechanical H-tunneling (QMHT) in hydroxycarbenes. To do so, we first selected a charge-tagged phenyl pyruvic acid derivative for our gas-phase study that delivers clean CO2-loss upon collision activation similarly to phenylhydroxycarbene, our first well characterized analyte [see M. Schäfer et al., Journal of the American Chemical Society 139 (2017) 5779−5786]. In this case however, we did not find any spectroscopic evidence for formation of the carbene intermediate, but identified exclusively the enol tautomer [see M. Paul, et al., Hydrogen Tunneling Avoided: Enol-Formation from a Charge-tagged Phenyl Pyruvic Acid Derivative Evidenced by Tandem-MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy and Theory, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 21 (2019) 16591-16600]. Subsequently, we paid close attention to the effects of intramolecular hydrogen bonding, specifically of C-H···꞉C hydrogen bonding interactions on QMHT kinetics of flexible aliphatic hydroxycarbenes. Due to its outspoken novelty, importance and scientific outcome, this study developed to the cornerstone of the projects conducted in this funding scheme, which culminated in a publication that certainly stands out in terms of thoroughness and impact on the field [M. Paul, et al., Hydrogen Bonding Shuts Down Tunneling in Hydroxycarbenes: A Gas-Phase Study by Tandem-Mass Spectrometry, Infrared Ion Spectroscopy, and Theory, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 145 (2023) 12124-12135]. In this outstanding paper, we report our findings on QMHT in a set of purposely designed linear and bicyclic aliphatic hydroxycarbenes. A focus lies on the effective inhibition of QMHT reactivity by intramolecular C:…H-C interactions. The exhaustive collection of tandem mass spectrometric, IR ion spectroscopic, computational and synthetic results presented in this article (and in the very large supporting information) represents and summarizes a large part of the work conducted in this project jointly pursued by A. Berkessel and M. Schäfer et al.. In the course of the above joint research efforts, we accomplished substantial progress in the indicated fields and beyond. We note that a substantial number of the proposed projects turned out to be very successful and fruitful, while the execution of a few others was hampered by technical difficulties, unexpected synthetic complications and unfortunate obstacles related to the COVID pandemic. Especially the integration of an electrospray ion source in a cryogenic ion trap proved to be more complicated than expected and led to the postponement of the fundamental investigations on quantum mechanical tunneling (QMT) at various low temperatures and at reduced back ground pressures. These pending parts of the research program will be addressed in a sequel project embedded in a MARIE Skłodowska-CURIE ACTIONS MSCA Doctoral Network (DN) proposed for funding to the European Union. Nevertheless, we collected numerous important results in the actual project period from 7-2018 to 12-2023 funded by the DFG (BE 998/16-1 & SCHA 871/10-1) which led to a remarkable number of important contributions published in highly ranked journals as listed below. Besides the substantial scientific progress, the DFG funding allowed us to provide interesting research projects and scientific training to a number of graduate students which enabled them to present hot topic results at national and international conferences, and thereby educate them on the highest possible level (AK Schäfer: Marcel Bast (PhD in Physics in the AK Schlemmer in 2024), Dennis Zeh (PhD in 2023), Leon Huenemeyer, PhD in Chemistry in the AK Schäfer in 2025; AK Berkessel: Graduate Student MSc Thomas Thomulka PhD 2021). In the following report we give a short overview on the results yielded in the DFG projects BE 998/16-1 & SCHA 871/10-1.
Publications
-
A Close Look on Structure and Reactivity of Catalysts, Metal-Complexes and Elusive Reaction Intermediates in the Gas Phase by Tandem-MS, and Theory, PACN Seminar, October 4th, Addis Ababa University, Ethiopia
Mathias Schäfer
-
Structure and Reactivity of Gas-Phase Phenylhydroxycarbenes: Hydrogen Tunneling at Room Temperature, Invited Hot Topic Talk, Bunsen Discussion Meeting on Gas-Phase Model Systems on Catalysis, 18.4.-20.4.2018, Ulm, Germany
Mathias Schäfer, Mathias Paul, Katrin Peckelsen, Jonathan Martens, Jos Oomens, Giel Berden, Albrecht Berkessel & Anthony J. H. M. Meijer
-
Hydrogen tunneling avoided: enol-formation from a charge-tagged phenyl pyruvic acid derivative evidenced by tandem-MS, IR ion spectroscopy and theory. Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 21(30), 16591-16600.
Paul, Mathias; Peckelsen, Katrin; Thomulka, Thomas; Neudörfl, Jörg; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Berkessel, Albrecht; Meijer, Anthony J. H. M. & Schäfer, Mathias
-
Hydrogen Tunneling Avoided: Formation of Enol Tautomers from a Charge-tagged Phenyl Pyruvic Acid Derivative Evidenced by Tandem-MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy and Theory, RSC Faraday Discussions Meeting on Advances in Ion Spectroscopy – From Astrophysics to Biology, 7.-9.4., York, UK
Mathias Schäfer, Mathias Paul, Katrin Peckelsen, Jonathan Martens, Giel Berden, Jos Oomens, Albrecht Berkessel & Anthony J. H. M. Meijer
-
Intermediates of N‐Heterocyclic Carbene (NHC) Dimerization Probed in the Gas Phase by Ion Mobility Mass Spectrometry: C−H⋅⋅⋅:C Hydrogen Bonding Versus Covalent Dimer Formation. Chemistry – A European Journal, 25(10), 2511-2518.
Paul, Mathias; Detmar, Eric; Schlangen, Maria; Breugst, Martin; Neudörfl, Jörg‐Martin; Schwarz, Helmut; Berkessel, Albrecht & Schäfer, Mathias
-
Intramolecular C...H-C Interactions Can Switch Off H-Tunneling Reactivity of Hydroxycarbenes; A Gas Phase Study by IR Ion Spectroscopy, Gordon Research Conference: From Small Atomic to Large Biomolecular Ions in Isolation, February 17 - 22, Ventura Beach, CA, USA
Mathias Schäfer, Thomas Thomulka, Katrin Peckelsen, Mathias Paul, Jonathan Martens, Jos Oomens, Giel Berden, Anthony J.H.M. Meijer & Albrecht Berkessel
-
Breslow Intermediates (Amino Enols) and Their Keto Tautomers: First Gas‐Phase Characterization by IR Ion Spectroscopy. Chemistry – A European Journal, 27(8), 2662-2669.
Paul, Mathias; Peckelsen, Katrin; Thomulka, Thomas; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Neudörfl, Jörg‐M.; Breugst, Martin; Meijer, Anthony J. H. M.; Schäfer, Mathias & Berkessel, Albrecht
-
Carbene Chemistry in the Gas Phase: H-tunneling of hydroxycarbenes and intramolecular C...H-C interactions studied by IR ion spectroscopy, Tandem-MS and Theory, CHAINS, digital conference
Mathias Schäfer
-
Hydrogen Tunneling in the Gas Phase Investigated by MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy, and Theory: First and Latest Results, 53. DGMS Jahrestagung, 1.3.-4.3.2020, Münster Germany. Keynote Lecture
Mathias Schäfer, Anthony Meijer, Thomas Thomulka, Katrin Peckelsen, Mathias Paul, Albrecht Berkessel, Jos Oomens, Giel Berden & Jonathan Martens
-
IRMPD Spectroscopic and Theoretical Structural Investigations of Zinc and Cadmium Dications Bound to Histidine Dimers. The Journal of Physical Chemistry A, 124(49), 10266-10276.
Stevenson, Brandon C.; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Schäfer, Mathias & Armentrout, P. B.
-
N-Heterocyclic Carbene (NHC) Dimerization in the Gas Phase: C-H···꞉C Hydrogen Bonding vs. Covalent Dimer Formation, ASIA-OCEANIA MASS SPECTROMETRY CONFERENCE, (AOMSC 2020), January 5-7, University of Macau, China. Invited Talk
Mathias Schäfer, Mathias Paul, Eric Detmar, Maria Schlangen, Martin Breugst, Jörg-Martin Neudörfl, Helmut Schwarz & Albrecht Berkessel
-
An investigation of inter-ligand coordination and flexibility: IRMPD spectroscopic and theoretical evaluation of calcium and nickel histidine dimers. Journal of Molecular Spectroscopy, 381, 111532.
Stevenson, Brandon C.; Peckelsen, Katrin; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Schäfer, Mathias & Armentrout, P.B.
-
Cryogenic Messenger-IR Ion Spectroscopy Study of Phenol & Aniline Molecular Ions and of the common Fragment Ion [C5H6]+ formed by EI-MS. Journal of Molecular Spectroscopy, 378, 111453.
Zeh, Dennis; Bast, Marcel; Rap, Daniël B.; Schmid, Philipp C.; Thorwirth, Sven; Brünken, Sandra; Schlemmer, Stephan & Schäfer, Mathias
-
Unidirectional Double- and Triple-Hydrogen Rearrangement Reactions Probed by Infrared Ion Spectroscopy. Journal of the American Society for Mass Spectrometry, 33(8), 1377-1392.
Zeh, Dennis; Bast, Marcel; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Brünken, Sandra; Schlemmer, Stephan; Schäfer, Mathias & Kuck, Dietmar
-
Discussion Leader at the Gordon Research Conference on Gaseous Ions: Structures, Energetics and Reactions, From Fundamentals to Emerging Applications, February 19 - 24, Ventura Beach, CA, USA
Mathias Schäfer
-
Hydrogen Bonding Shuts Down H-Tunneling in Hydroxycarbenes: A Gas-Phase Study by Tandem-MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy, and Theory, Faraday joint interest group conference, 3.-5. April, University Sheffield, UK
Mathias Paul, Thomas Thomulka, Wacharee Harnying, Jörg-M. Neudörfl, Charlie Adams, Jonathan Martens, Giel Berden, Jos Oomens, Anthony J. H. M. Meijer, Albrecht Berkessel & Mathias Schäfer, C.
-
Hydrogen Bonding Shuts Down H-Tunneling in Hydroxycarbenes: A Gas-Phase Study by Tandem-MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy, and Theory, Gordon Research Conference on Gaseous Ions: Structures, Energetics and Reactions, From Fundamentals to Emerging Applications, February 19 - 24, Ventura Beach, CA, USA
Mathias Paul, Thomas Thomulka, Wacharee Harnying, Jörg-M. Neudörfl, Charlie Adams, Jonathan Martens, Giel Berden, Jos Oomens, Anthony J. H. M. Meijer, Albrecht Berkessel & Mathias Schäfer, C.
-
Hydrogen Bonding Shuts Down Tunneling in Hydroxycarbenes: A Gas-Phase Study by Tandem-Mass Spectrometry, Infrared Ion Spectroscopy, and Theory. Journal of the American Chemical Society, 145(22), 12124-12135.
Paul, Mathias; Thomulka, Thomas; Harnying, Wacharee; Neudörfl, Jörg-Martin; Adams, Charlie R.; Martens, Jonathan; Berden, Giel; Oomens, Jos; Meijer, Anthony J. H. M.; Berkessel, Albrecht & Schäfer, Mathias
-
Curtius and Wolff Rearrangement Reactions investigated by Tandem-MS, IR Ion Spectroscopy (IRIS) and Theory, INTERNATIONAL MASS SPECTROMETRY CONFERENCE 2024, AUGUST 17-23, MELBOURNE, AUSTRALIA
Mathias Schäfer, Giel Berden, Jonathan Martens, Jos Oomens, Hui-Chung Wen, Wacharee Harnying, Albrecht Berkessel, Jana Roithová & Anthony J. H. M. Meijer
