A motor-priming approach to embodied cognition: Forceful tests with numerical tasks
Final Report Abstract
Numerous studies have provided evidence of a close connection between numbers and space such that larger numbers are associated with the right side of space, while smaller numbers are linked to the left side. This phenomenon is referred to as Spatial-Numerical Association (SNA) and has been extensively documented. Additionally, vertical SNA effects have been reported in various studies. The connection between space, number, and action can be explained by "A Theory of Magnitude" (ATOM) proposed by Walsh (2003; 2014). According to this theory, magnitudes, including numerical magnitude, time, and quantities, are processed in common frontoparietal areas of the brain. As a result, numerical magnitude is closely linked to perceptual and motor magnitudes, effectively connecting number, perception, and action. An alternative view by Fischer (2012) introduced a conceptual framework that distinguishes between hierarchically organized grounded, embodied, and situated levels of number representation and processing, providing insight into different origins for spatial associations of numbers. While evolutionary constraints relate to grounding and sensory-motor experiences relate to embodiment, situated influences on SNAs reflect current task constraints such as body posture. Although SNAs are well-established for individual numbers, the interaction of number representations and space within mathematical tasks remains a topic of debate. Shaki et al. (2018) proposed the arithmetic heuristics and biases (AHAB) model, which identifies three competing mechanisms of numerical cognition: a more-or-less heuristic, a sign-space association, and an anchoring bias. These arithmetic biases are linked to the three-level hierarchy of embodied cognition mentioned earlier. This project aimed to explore the effects of directional isometric force on spatial-numerical associations across three conceptual levels, reflecting grounded, embodied, and situated cognition. The first objective of this project was to examine predictions about congruency effects derived from the hierarchical embodiment of cognition, following the AHAB model proposed by Shaki et al. (2018). This examination was carried out within the context of a single-digit arithmetic task (SDA). Secondly, the project also focused on random number generation (RNG) as a form of situated number processing. The sensitivity of this task to momentary constraints, such as the exerted force vector, was of particular interest. Prior to this study, no research had explored the effect of number production on force production. The comparison involved numbers generated under specific conditions, such as left/right and up/down, as well as force profiles for small and large numbers. The primary focus was on exploring how action, specifically isometric force, affects spatial-numerical associations along the horizontal and vertical cardinal axes. The force was measured using a force sensor that ensures heigh temporal resolution.
Publications
-
A Developmental Embodied Choice Perspective Explains the Development of Numerical Choices. Frontiers in Psychology, 12.
Michirev, Alexej; Musculus, Lisa & Raab, Markus
-
Location, Timing, and Magnitude of Embodied Language Processing: Methods and Results. Handbook of Embodied Psychology, 245-263.
Gianelli, Claudia & Kühne, Katharina
-
Separation/connection procedures: From cleansing behavior to numerical cognition. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 44.
Felisatti, Arianna; Fischer, Martin H.; Kulkova, Elena; Kühne, Katharina & Michirev, Alexej
-
Where is your time? Focus on spatial language activates horizontal time representations [Conference talk]. Embodied and Situated Language Processing Conference. Current Directions and Future Perspectives (ESLP 2021), online
Kühne, K. & Miklashevsky, A.
-
Situated flexibility of time concepts: The role of task [Conference talk]. 22nd meeting of the European Society for Cognitive Psychology (ESCoP 2022), Lille, France
Miklashevsky, A. & Kühne, K.
-
Space-valence mapping of social concepts: Do we arrange negative and positive ethnic stereotypes from left to right?. Frontiers in Psychology, 13.
Kühne, K.; Nenaschew, K. & Miklashevsky, A.
-
The connection of force and number magnitude is measured in the hand. [Conference talk]. 64th Conference of Experimental Psychologists (TeaP 2023), Cologne, Germany
Michirev, A.; Raab, M.; Fischer, M. H.; Kühne, K. & Lindemann, O.
-
Theoretical position on embodied bounded rationality: The body is an informant for choices. [Conference talk]. 52nd Congress of the German Psychological Society (DGPS 2022), Hildesheim, Germany
Michirev, A.; Musculus, L. & Raab, M.
-
Automatic activation of grip force magnitude during number magnitude processing. [Poster presentation]. 65th Conference of Experimental Psychologists (Teap 2023), Trier, Germany
Michirev, A.; Kühne, K.; Lindemann, O.; Fischer, M. H. & Raab, M.
-
Deine Finger sind kleine Mathe-Genies! Stichting In-Mind Foundation
Michirev, A.; Iskra, M. & Voigt, L.
-
How to not induce SNAs: The insufficiency of directional force. PLOS ONE, 18(6), e0288038.
Michirev, A.; Kühne, K.; Lindemann, O.; Fischer, M. H. & Raab, M.
-
In first wave COVID-19 survivors cognitive inhibition mediates the effect of insomnia on the strength of the Operation sign spatial association [Poster presentation]. European Workshop in Cognitive Neuropsychology (EWCN), Bressanone, Italy
Kühne, Canessa, N.; Rossato, F. & Gianelli, C.
-
Negation has a size! Number magnitude corresponds with set-size in linguistic negation [Poster presentation]. 10th Mind, Brain, Body Symposium (MBBS), Berlin, Germany, March 14–17, 2023
Jeglinski-Mende, M. A. & Kühne, K.
-
The SNARC effect relies on an allocentric frame of reference [Poster presentation]. 10th Mind, Brain, Body Symposium (MSSB), Berlin, Germany
Kühne, K.; Lindemann, O. & Fischer, M. H.
