The Political Difference of Life: For a Reconceptualization of the Crisis of State and Society
Final Report Abstract
The project "The Political Difference of Life" aimed at bringing together two strands of the philosophical discussion of the modern form of politics and its crisis: on the one hand, the discussion about the difference between state and society and, on the other, the discourse about biopolitics. The project assumed that by bringing them together one could better understand not only what modern politics consists of, but also why it is in crisis. In descriptive terms, the project sought to gain a new and more adequate understanding of the relationship between state and society through the discussion of the biopolitical concept of life. At the same time, the project aimed to clarify in normative terms how the difference in this relationship is to be determined in order to provide an answer to the current crisis of politics. To pursue those aims, three steps were considered necessary: first, to develop a concept of life determined by its immanent difference; second, to work out the difference of life from its other (the political form); third, to rethink in this way the relation of the life of society to the state. The critical reconstruction of the relationship between state and society formed the background for a series of events that took place in the first year of funding: workshops with Jean-François Kervégan, Marietta Auer and Joseph Vogl. The interdisciplinary exchange in this workshop series provided important insights for the next steps of the project. It was precisely in the crisis, it turned out, that the form of social life is to be understood in such a way that it is conceived as self-regulating and yet can neither be separated from politics nor reduced to it. In a next step, we organized an international conference on Georg Lukács ("Self-Transformative Life: Lukács and the Critique of Capitalism"), considering that in his work reflections on the crisis of the modern state are closely and fundamentally connected to a specific concept of life. The conference aimed at exploring whether and to what extent descriptive and normative resources can be gained from this understanding of life as a selftransformative process. In doing so, this event contributed to a better understanding of the notion of a "potentiality" of life. Returning to reflections on the relationship between state and society, we organized an international conference on "The Crisis of Freedom: Hegel's Elements of the Philosophy of Right after 200 Years" which took place in 2022. This event explored the logic and relevance of those social and political crises that Hegel focused on in his Grundlinien and that are current today in altered guises. In the same year took place the final conference of our research project, titled "The Return of the Authoritarian Character: Crises of Neoliberal Biopolitics". The aim was to combine the findings of three fields of the project in the interpretation and analysis of a contemporary phenomenon, so that we could understand the current crisis more precisely in descriptive terms through our reflections on a biopolitical conceptualization of the relationship between state and society. In normative terms, we have been guided by the question of the possibility of a genuinely democratic biopolitics.
Publications
-
Direito e violência. Estudos críticos, hrsg. von João Paulo Bachur/Antonio Martins, São Paula: Saraiva.
Menke, Ch.
-
DO SINGULAR AO COMUM?. Revista Inter-Legere, 2(24), 81-117.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Einheit im Normativen: Der Geist der Gesetze als Problem der Moderne. Schweizerische Zeitschrift für Philosophie, 78(StPh78).
Heller, Jonas
-
Füreinander Sprechen. Zu einer feministischen Theorie der Repräsentation. Leviathan, 47(3), 331-353.
Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
Simmel and the forms of in-dividuality. Religious Individualisation, 409-436. De Gruyter.
Bueno, Arthur
-
The Value of Critique. Exploring the Interrelations of Value, Critique, and Artistic Labour, Frankfurt am Main: Campus.
Graw, I. & Menke, Ch.
-
„Democratic Citizenship and Subjective Rights: Marx’s Riddle“, in: Olivier Beaud/Catherine Colliot-Thélène/Jean-François Kervégan (Hg.), Droits subjectifs et citoyenneté, Paris: Classiques Garnier, S. 97-107.
Menke, Ch.
-
„Der Zwang zur Tragödie. Zur Selbstdurchbrechung des Politischen bei Carl Schmitt“, in: Deutsche Zeitschrift für Philosophie – Zweimonatsschrift der internationalen philosophischen Forschung 67/6, 952-973.
Heller, J.
-
Economic pathologies of life. The Routledge International Handbook of Simmel Studies, 336-349. Routledge.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Kommentar zu Teil II: Die Grenzen der Moral und die Demokratisierung der Grenze. Der Begriff des Flüchtlings, 199-206. J.B. Metzler.
Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
Life-protecting neoliberalism: Hayek and the biopolitics of abortion in Chile. Economy and Society, 49(4), 596-618.
Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
The Crisis of Liberalism. Debating Critical Theory, 225-244. The Rowman & Littlefield Publishing Group.
Menke, Christoph
-
The Post-Depressive Constellation. Democracy and Brazil, 114-129. Routledge.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Verfassung und subjektive Rechte. Die Idee subjektiver Rechte, 125-134. De Gruyter.
Menke, Christoph
-
¿Qué viene después de la depresión? Ocho tesis sobre la crisis de la subjetividad neoliberal y sus implicancias políticas. Cuadernos de Teoría Social, 6(11), 95-120.
Bueno, Arthur
-
„Naturverhältnisse in der Krise: Gesellschaftliches Handeln und natürliche Prozessualität in der COVID-19-Pandemie“, in: Zeitschrift für Praktische Philosophie 7/2, 467–498.
Heller, J.
-
„Sicherheit im Namen der Freiheit. Die liberale Ordnung und das ‚Leben der Nation‘, in: Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie Beiheft 162, 43-57.
Heller, J.
-
„The Non-Normative Order of the Social“, in: Navigating Normative Orders. Interdisciplinary Perspectives, hg. v. Matthias Kettemann, Frankfurt/New York: Campus, 59-74.
Martinez Mateo, Marina & Heller, Jonas
-
Aufhören oder Weiterdenken? Zur Frage des Umgangs mit Carl Schmitt. Eine Debatte mit Jean-François Kervégan. Rechtsphilosophie, 7(2), 115-119.
Heller, Jonas & Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
Autoritärer Neoliberalismus und Verfassungsgebung in Chile. Überlegungen zum Verhältnis von Diktatur und Rechtsstaat. Politik im Rechtsstaat, 239-260. Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft mbH & Co. KG.
Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
Critical Theory and New Materialisms. Routledge.
Rosa, H.; Henning, C.& Bueno, A.
-
Pathology and vitality. Critical Theory and New Materialisms, 123-139. Routledge.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Souveränität der Plattform. Eine Debatte mit Joseph Vogl, Zeitschriftenschwerpunkt mit Beiträgen von Joseph Vogl, Francesca Raimondi, Frieder Vogelmann und Ute Tellmann, in: Behemoth. A Journal on Civilisation 14/1 (Sonderausgabe).
Martinez Mateo, Marina & Heller, Jonas (Hg.)
-
The Post-Depressive Constellation: From Political Effervescence to the Rise of Right-Wing Authoritarianism in Brazil. Krisis | Journal for Contemporary Philosophy, 41(1), 45-64.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Zum Umgang mit Carl Schmitt. Eine Debatte mit Jean-François Kervégan, Zeitschriftenschwerpunkt mit Beiträgen von Marietta Auer, Klaus Günther, Jens Hacke, Anna-Bettina Kaiser und Jean-François Kervégan, in: Rechtsphilosophie. Zeitschrift für Grundlagen des Rechts (RphZ) 7/2.
Martinez Mateo, Marina & Heller, Jonas (Hg.)
-
„Das Problem des Volkes. Möglichkeiten einer Kritik der Repräsentation“, in: M. Neubauer (et al.) (Hg.): Im Namen des Volkes. Zur Kritik politischer Repräsentation. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 177–200.
Martinez Mateo, Marina
-
„The Experiment of Freedom“, in: Emmerling, L. u.a. (Hg.): Museum | Futures, Wien-Berlin: Turia + Kant, S. 40-59.
Menke, Ch.
-
De-Centering Global Sociology. Routledge.
Bueno, Arthur; Teixeira, Mariana & Strecker, David
-
Ein gemeinsames Leben?. Abschied vom Individuum?, 91-116. Brill | Schöningh.
Bueno, Arthur
-
The standpoint of the proletariat today. De-Centering Global Sociology, 161-177. Routledge.
Bueno, Arthur
-
Theorie der Befreiung, Berlin: Suhrkamp.
Menke, Ch.
-
„Die Vormacht des Allgemeinen. Über die Funktion des Rechts als ideologischem Staatsapparat bei Adorno und Neumann“, in: Archiv für Rechts- und Sozialphilosophie
Gurisch, S.
-
Self-transformative life and social critique. Distinktion: Journal of Social Theory, 25(3), 427-434.
Bueno, Arthur & Gurisch, Simon
