Back to the Future: Archiving Residential Children’s Homes (ARCH) in Scotland and Germany
Final Report Abstract
Many people who have spent a period of their lives in residential care have the problem that they have only inadequate biographical memory aids of their own upbringing. Against this background, the transnational study investigated the possibilities and limits of an identity-forming memory of childhood, youth and shared everyday life by means of (community) archival records of residential care in Scotland and Germany. As part of a three phased approach, historical, current and future archival materials were analysed as possible memorabilia. The historically oriented analysis of the archival materials of two institutional archives made it clear that for decades little relevance was given to archiving shared everyday life – this also applies in particular to the transmission of young people's perspectives. As many historical archival records were also not accessible to care experienced people, only a very limited potential for identity forming memory could be determined for both institutional archives. With regard to the present and future, the investigation of the participatory development of 'living' digital community archives with current members of two residential care homes, respectively one in each country, showed that community archiving based on the relevancies and perspectives of young people had a high potential to support identity forming memories. In the Scottish residential group, working with specially developed archiving software was seen as an enriching addition to the collection of individual memory aids for young people, which is now required by law. In the German residential group, the associated creation of community archival records served to deal with the recording and accessibility of memory aids for young people for the first time, away from organisation centred case files. In addition, during the collaborative archiving with children and young people, numerous practices of shared biographical memory of everyday experiences and developments could be reconstructed, which already proved to be identity forming for the participants in the present. On the one hand, the study illustrated the unique potential of digital community archives, which can significantly enrich a culture of archiving and remembrance in the context of residential care that is now established in Scotland and needs to be expanded in Germany. On the other hand, a professional assumption of responsibility for the memory needs of future care leavers, up-to-date digital infrastructures and an adequate amount of staff and time are important conditions for success in order to exploit the potential of digital community archives in the future.
Publications
-
Digitale Gruppenarchive als alternative Erinnerungsstützen zu individuellen Fallkaten – Grundlagen und Ergebnisse einer transnationalen Studie. In: Forum Erziehungshilfe, H. 3
Emond, Ruth & Burns, Andrew
-
Living Archives – Heimerziehung erinnern. Vortrag im Rahmen der Veranstaltung Sozialpädagogische Abendgespräche, 14.12.2021, Technische Universität Dortmund
Eßer, Florian & Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Back to the future: Memory archiving of residential children as a cross-generational responsibility. Vortrag auf dem Bundeskongress der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Erziehungswissenschaft (DGfE), Universität Bremen
Lucas, Sian & Haskenhoff, J.
-
Back to the Future: Archiving Residential Children’s Homes in Scotland and Germany (2023): The Scottish Findings. Phase One Report: Analysis of the archives from 1920-1980
Eßer, Florian & Thelen, Tobias
-
Erinnerbare Jugend in Freistätter Erziehungsheimen. Befunde zur kustodialen Geschichtsarchivierung am Beispiel des Hauptarchivs Bethel. Vortrag im Kolloquium des Instituts für Diakonie- und Sozialgeschichte, 15.02.2023, Bielefeld
Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Erinnerbare Kindheit und Jugend in Heimerziehung. Befunde zur kustodialen Archivierung des Heimalltags am Beispiel Freistatt. Neue Praxis, 2023 (2), 121–138
Schäfer, Maximilian & Eßer, Florian
-
Erinnerungsstützen für Care Leaver:innen – Ergebnisse zu sozialpädagogischen Erinnerungsstützen für Care Leaver:innen. Abendvortrag auf der Empirie AG der Kommission Sozialpädagogik der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Erziehungswissenschaft (DGfE), 30.06.23, Bielefeld
Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Heimerziehung erinnern. Sozial Extra, 47(6), 358-362.
Schäfer, Maximilian & Eßer, Florian
-
Heimerziehung gemeinsam erinnern – Zwischenergebnisse zur Entwicklung digitaler Gemeinschaftsarchive für Wohngruppen. Forum Erziehungshilfen(5), 305-309.
Heyen, Malte; Schäfer, Maximilian; Eßer, Florian & Thelen, Tobias
-
Supporting Memories of a Shared Everyday Life. Findings on the Development of Digital Group Archives for Members of Residential Care Homes. Vortrag auf der Conference of the European Scientific Association on the Residential and Foster Care for Children and Adolescents (EuSARF), 13.09.2023, University of Sussex, England
Eßer, Florian; Schäfer, Maximilian & Emond, Ruth
-
Verwahrte und bewahrte Zeiten - Befunde zu Archivierungspolitiken in der Heimerziehung. Vortrag nach Peer Review auf der Jahrestagung der Kommission Sozialpädagogik der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Erziehungswissenschaft (DGfE) 24.03.23, Universität Rostock
Schäfer, Maximilian & Eßer, Florian
-
Archiving Residential Children’s Homes. Konzeption und Befunde einer Studie über das Erinnern an Heimerziehung. Vortrag im Forschungsnetzwerk Erziehungshilfen, 12.10.23, Universität Hildesheim
Schäfer, Maximilian & Eßer, Florian
-
Back to the Future: Archiving Residential Children’s Homes in Scotland and Germany (2024): The Scottish Findings. Phase Two Briefing Report
Eßer, Florian & Thelen, Tobias
-
Developing a group archive – the processes and challenges. Vortrag auf der Tagung Treasuring memories: Findings from ARCH, 20.06.2024, University of Stirling, Scotland
Heyen, Malte & Lucas, Sian
-
Digital group archives in residential childcare: an investigation into memory responsibility. Families, Relationships and Societies, 1-17.
Lucas, Sian E.; Burns, Andrew; Emond, Ruth & Reid, Laura
-
Erinnerungsstützen für Care Leaver:innen. Befunde transnationaler Forschung. Vortrag auf der Tagung der Arbeitsgruppe Adressat*innnenforschung/Nutzer*innenforschung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Soziale Arbeit (DGSA), 23.11.2024, Hochschule Wiesbaden
Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Everyday records or living archives? An analysis of record-keeping in residential children’s homes in Scotland. Archives and Records, 45(3), 288-305.
Emond, Ruth; Burns, Andrew; Hagan, Hugh & Magee, Karl
-
Soon I'll know again what was going on here and what I was like - Findings of Archiving Residential Children's Homes in Germany. Vortrag auf der Tagung "Treasuring memories: Findings from ARCH, 20.06.2024, University of Stirling, Scotland
Schäfer, Maximilian & Eßer, Florian
-
Vom Erinnerungsbedarf der Organisation zum Erinnerungsbedarf der Adressat*innen. Zum Transformationsbedarf archivgestützter Rückblicke auf Heimerziehung. Vortrag auf der Jahrestagung der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Soziale Arbeit (DGSA), 27.04.24, Ernst Abbe Hochschule Jena
Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Aktenführung, Archivierung und Erinnerung in stationären Erziehungshilfen – Adressat*innenorientierte Überlegungen. Forum Erziehungshilfen(3), 132-136.
Eßer, Florian & Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Between plans and realities: Reflecting on experiences of participatory research in archiving residential Children’s homes in Scotland and Germany. Qualitative Social Work, 24(6), 721-737.
Burns, Andrew & Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Fallakten als Erinnerungsstützen für Care Leaver:innen. Soziale Arbeit, 74(2), 42-49.
Schäfer, Maximilian
-
Finding traces of everyday life in unusual places: looking beyond case files in German and Scottish residential child care. European Journal of Social Work, 28(6), 1214-1226.
Emond, Ruth; Eßer, Florian; Schäfer, Max; Buncombe, Miriam; Burns, Andrew; Lucas, Sian & Magee, Karl
-
When the hell is going on? Ontopolitiken der Zeit in sozialpädagogischen Konstellationen. In: Kommission Sozialpädagogik (Hg.): Sozialpädagogische*s Zeit*en
Flack, N.; Eßer, F..; von der Heyde, J.; Jäde, S.; Nicolas, J. & Schäfer, M.
