A face to be loved or feared? A follow-up on interindividual differences and clinical implications
Personality Psychology, Clinical and Medical Psychology, Methodology
Final Report Abstract
This project investigated how verbal learning about potential threats modulates face and person perception. Various social-emotional factors were examined (e.g., emotional facial expressions, face identity, and pictures of loved ones), either as threat or safety cues or in threatening or safe contextual settings. Perceptual processing, memory encoding and recognition, as well as psychophysiological responding and overt behavior were examined. In addition to replicating previous findings on the processing of threats and faces, several important findings can be highlighted from this project. 1) Verbal threat instructions lead to selective perceptual processing, encoding and activation of psychophysiological defense systems, when confronted with presumed threat cues or contexts. Here, it does not matter that the threat cue is actually never followed by the anticipated aversive event. 2) Verbal threat instructions flexibly change previous face-, person-, and context-related associations. The instructions easily override the implicit affective meaning of facial stimuli, e.g. a smiling person or even pictures of familiar loved ones can easily become new threat cues. 3) Instructed contextual threat or safety changes how we perceive and respond to other people. Context helps to understand ambiguous information (e.g., to better recognize a subtle fearful expression in a threatening environment), and to draw attention to deviant and unexpected information (e.g., a smiling face in an aversive situation). Moreover, simply looking at a picture of a smiling person or a loved one does not impede functional defensive responding to aversive experimental conditions. 4) Verbal threat instructions lead to surprisingly persistent defensive reactions that are less accessible to passive extinction learning, i.e. the proof of safety is particularly difficult if threat has been acquired socially (i.e., without own CS-US experience). 5) These threat-biases likely reflect the workings of healthy functional and adaptive mechanisms that are partially subject to interindividual differences. For example, individuals with adverse childhood experiences showed intact selective threat processing for newly acquired threat associations, and a transdiagnostic sample (including borderline and PTSD patients) showed adaptive threat-potentiated startle to instructed threat cues. 6) Clinical relevance arises in particular with regard to threat-safety reversal learning, which involves both the acquisition of new and concurrent inhibition of previous threat associations. Here, in individuals with subclinical and clinical relevant anxious psychopathology, for example, less neural differentiation between new and old threat cues was observed as well as enhanced distrust to actually safe persons. Overall, the role of social learning in person perception and psychophysiological responding is still under-researched. Here, the project results come together to form an integrative neuroscientific model of face and person perception as a function of social learning, with implications for clinical research.
Link to the final report
https://doi.org/10.23668/psycharchives.21396
Publications
-
Verbal instructions override the meaning of facial expressions. Scientific Reports, 8(1).
Bublatzky, Florian; Guerra, Pedro & Alpers, Georg W.
-
Modulation of face- and emotion-selective ERPs by the three most common types of face image manipulations. Social Cognitive and Affective Neuroscience, 14(5), 493-503.
Schindler, Sebastian; Bruchmann, Maximilian; Bublatzky, Florian & Straube, Thomas
-
Reversing Threat to Safety: Incongruence of Facial Emotions and Instructed Threat Modulates Conscious Perception but Not Physiological Responding. Frontiers in Psychology, 10.
Bublatzky, Florian; Riemer, Martin & Guerra, Pedro
-
Attention and emotion: An integrative review of emotional face processing as a function of attention. Cortex, 130, 362-386.
Schindler, Sebastian & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Contextual information resolves uncertainty about ambiguous facial emotions: Behavioral and magnetoencephalographic correlates. NeuroImage, 215, 116814.
Bublatzky, Florian; Kavcıoğlu, Fatih; Guerra, Pedro; Doll, Sarah & Junghöfer, Markus
-
Contextual source information modulates neural face processing in the absence of conscious recognition: A threat-of-shock study. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 174, 107280.
Schellhaas, Sabine; Arnold, Nina; Schmahl, Christian & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Threat rapidly disrupts reward reversal learning. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 131, 103636.
Paret, Christian & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Watch out, he's dangerous! Electrocortical indicators of selective visual attention to allegedly threatening persons. Cortex, 131, 164-178.
Bublatzky, Florian; Guerra, Pedro & Alpers, Georg W.
-
A multinomial modelling approach to face identity recognition during instructed threat. Cognition and Emotion, 35(7), 1302-1319.
Arnold, Nina R.; González, Cruz Hernán; Schellhaas, Sabine & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Instructed threat enhances threat perception in faces.. Emotion, 21(2), 419-429.
Kavcıoğlu, Fatih C.; Bublatzky, Florian; Pittig, Andre & Alpers, Georg W.
-
Verbal threat learning does not spare loved ones. Scientific Reports, 11(1).
Morato, Cristina; Guerra, Pedro & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Aversive anticipations modulate electrocortical correlates of decision-making and reward reversal learning, but not behavioral performance. Frontiers in Behavioral Neuroscience, 16.
Bublatzky, Florian; Schellhaas, Sabine & Paret, Christian
-
Social threat and safety learning in individuals with adverse childhood experiences: electrocortical evidence on face processing, recognition, and working memory. European Journal of Psychotraumatology, 13(2).
Schellhaas, Sabine; Schmahl, Christian & Bublatzky, Florian
-
The mere sight of loved ones does not inhibit psychophysiological defense mechanisms when threatened. Scientific Reports, 12(1).
Bublatzky, Florian; Schellhaas, Sabine & Guerra, Pedro
-
A partner's smile is not per se a safety signal: Psychophysiological response patterns to instructed threat and safety. Psychophysiology, 60(6).
Morato, Cristina; Guerra, Pedro & Bublatzky, Florian
-
Incidental learning of faces during threat: No evidence for enhanced physiological responses to former threat identities. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 205, 107838.
Schellhaas, Sabine; Schmahl, Christian & Bublatzky, Florian
