Organisationale Kriminalität und systemische Korruption in Brasilien
Kriminologie
Politikwissenschaft
Soziologische Theorie
Strafrecht
Zusammenfassung der Projektergebnisse
The research project aimed to identify and explain the patterns of corporate crime and political corruption in Brazil, employing a mixed-methods approach that combined both qualitative and quantitative methodologies. This comprehensive approach analyzed data related to four major corruption and illegal electoral financing cases, each known by their investigative and judicial processes (operations): (1) Lava Jato (Car Wash), (2) Mensalao, (3) Satiagraha, and (4) Castelo de Areia. These case studies provided access to a wealth of publicly available data from 77 judicial proceedings involving illegal transactions between Brazilian state officials, key figures from major contracting firms, informal brokers, and intermediaries—many of whom were convicted. Using extensive documentation from the Brazilian judicial system, the researchers created a dataset of criminal cases and later conducted interviews with 71 individuals involved in the cases, including perpetrators, witnesses, judges, prosecutors, and attorneys. The findings were disseminated through various academic publications and other contributions. The data from judicial documents and interviews informed a multi-level framework that initially included an institutional analysis and other qualitative methods especially, the collective mindset analysis. The study's findings not only contributed to unveiling the modus operandi of organizational misconduct by companies and political parties but also focused on the underlying mindsets of both perpetrators and law enforcement officials. Although the research was primarily based on qualitative methods, quantitative analyses were also employed, particularly in constructing a prosopography of the individuals involved in rule-breaking behavior and examining the varied anti-corruption responses when brought before the judicial system, according to the groups perpetrators belonged. The research centered on three key questions: (1) How do economic and political corruption operate systematically within the case studies? (2) How effective have institutional and organizational regulations been in combating corruption and corporate crime? (3) What role does the anti-corruption regime play in shaping the evolving patterns of corruption within political and economic organizations, as well as in influencing collective mindsets? To address these questions, the researchers drew on new institutionalist theory to assess the functioning of organizations through both formal and informal rules. Additionally, they applied rational choice theory and criminological concepts to explain deviant behavior in several of their publications.
Projektbezogene Publikationen (Auswahl)
-
Environmental Liability and Organizational Deviance: Evidence from Informal Rules in a Dam Collapse, oral presentation in the Panel Crime and Deviance in Brazil, in: ECPR SGOC General Conference, University of Sofia, Bulgaria, 5-6 July.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
Organizational crime and corruption in Brazil a case study of the “Operation Carwash” court records. International Journal of Law, Crime and Justice, 59, 100340.
Valarini, Elizangela & Pohlmann, Markus
-
Special Issue Organisierte Regelverletzungen – Jenseits der Moral. In: Journal of Self-Regulation and Regulation, Vol. 5. (eISSN 2365-8959)
Pohlmann, Markus; Dannecker, G.; Valarini, Elizangela & Höly, K.
-
Systemic Corruption in Brazil: An Autopsy of the Odebrecht Case. In: Journal of Self-Regulation and Regulation, Vol. 5, S. 55-78.
Pohlmann, Markus; Valarini, Elizangela; Trombini, Maria Eugenia & Jorge, Mario H.
-
The Fight against Corruption in International Comparison, oral presentation on in: China-Europe Relations in Uncertainties and Unintended Consequences, Shanghai, China, September.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
Collective mindset and the narrative of corruption: international benchmark and Brazilian practice, oral presentation at LASA, May 13-16, 2020 in Guadalajara, Mexico,
Valarini, Elizangela & Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
Corruption as a Collective Crime: the Case of Brazil and Odebrecht, oral presentation at LASA 2020, May 13-16, 2020 in Guadalajara, Mexico
Jorge, Mario H. & Pohlmann, Markus
-
Lawyers as Enablers of Wrongdoing: Challenges Faced by Democracies Regarding Corruption and Money Laundering. Political Corruption and Organizational Crime, 309-340. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Jorge, Mario H.
-
Misuse of Public Office for Organizational Gain? Brazilian Political Parties in Corruption Scandals. Political Corruption and Organizational Crime, 267-308. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
Populist grammar, politicians and judges: a case study of political corruption in Brazil. Populism and Corruption. Edward Elgar Publishing.
Valarini, Elizangela & Eugenia, Trombini Maria
-
The Fight Against Corruption in Brazil: A Case of Good Governance? Knowledge for Governance, 225–241.
Pohlmann, Markus & Valarini, Elizangela
-
‘Culture’, Criminality and Collective Mindset: Political Financing in Brazil. Political Corruption and Organizational Crime, 125–152.
Valarini, Elizangela
-
"Korruption in Brasilien", paper presentation in the interdisciplinary conference "Making rules, breaking rules: Law, Crime and Society", in June, held online & in person, in Heidelberg
Valarini, Elizangela & Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
A case study of systemic corruption in the state health bureaucracy. Corona und Korruption, 105-153. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia; Jorge, Mario H.; Valarini, Elizangela & Pohlmann, Markus
-
"(Un) Avoidable Organizational Crime – A Qualitative Case Study of Andrade Gutierrez SA.", paper presentation at the panel "Contractors, Corruption, and the Functioning of Democracy" under the Research Committee on Political Finance and Political Corruption, at the 27th World Congress of Political Science. July 15th-19th, 2023, Buenos Aires.
Jorge, Mario H. & Santos, R. B.
-
Compliance, Integrity, and Prevention in the Corporate Sector: The Collective Mindsets of Compliance Officers in the USA. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität, 319-358. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Pohlmann, Markus & Starystach, Sebastian
-
Formal Rules and Institutional Increments in Brazil. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität, 361-375. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Jorge, Mário H.
-
How to Analyze Organizational Crime – Theory, Concepts, and Methods. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität, 19-61. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Pohlmann, Markus
-
Legal Professionals in White-Collar Crime. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
Organizational Crime in Brazil: The Petrobras Case. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität, 377-401. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Valarini, Elizângela
-
The Anti-Corruption Mindset of Brazilian Law Enforcers. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität, 403-420. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia & Valarini, Elizângela
-
Odebrecht case. Elgar Encyclopedia of Corruption and Society, 210-213. Edward Elgar Publishing.
de Oliveira, Vanessa Elias & Trombini, Maria Eugenia
-
The Fight against Systemic Corruption. Organization, Management and Crime - Organisation, Management und Kriminalität. Springer Fachmedien Wiesbaden.
Trombini, Maria Eugenia; Valarini, Elizangela; Elias, de Oliveira Vanessa & Pohlmann, Markus
-
“Existem evidências quantitativas de viés partidário nas sentenças da Operação Lava Jato?” Article published in Brazilian Studies and Anticorruption Practices Network, a blog by the iniciative of Transparency International.
Da Ros, L.; Trombini, Maria Eugenia & Vilaça, L.
